¬ just serendipity 🍀 (not just serendipity)

doas is a lightweight and safer replacement for sudo. In most occasions you invoke it exactly like sudo:

$ sudo apt install <foo>
$ doas apt install <foo>

doas has gained popularity recently. Besides being the default in OpenBSD, Alpine Linux 3.15 (released last year) has also switched to it:

doas is the default temporary privilege escalation tool. You are advised to migrate from sudo to doas as 3.15 will be the last release to support sudo throughout its full lifecycle, in 3.16 sudo will be moved from main to community.

It’s not very difficult to get used to it, however you may still find yourself writing sudo occasionally. This post highlights a few ways to bridge that gap.

Use a shell alias #

In your ~/.bashrc or ~/.zshrc or in your favorite shell, do:

alias sudo=doas

Caveat: Besides being an user-dependent workaround¹, doas isn’t really a full drop-in replacement to sudo. This workaround will work in most day-to-day situations but it will obviously not support most sudo specific flags.

Use a shim/wrapper (recommended) #

Alpine Linux provides a doas-sudo-shim package:

$ doas apk add doas-sudo-shim

This is a shim for the sudo command that utilizes doas. It supports only a subset of the sudo options (both short and long variants) that have an equivalent in doas, plus option -i (--login).

This is a slightly better solution, as this thin wrapper is aware of some sudo flags, translating them to the equivalent doas ones; furthermore, it works out-of-the-box and it’s system-wide. As an added bonus, it’s implemented entirely in shell script, being as much portable as possible.

Final remarks #

Last but not least, you could choose to install sudo and configure it, keeping both doas and sudo, but what’s the point? If your system favours doas, stick to doas. There’s no need to unnecessarily increase complexity by keeping around two programs that serve exactly the same purpose.

If you don’t like or want doas for some reason, you could look into the other way around: find a doas shim that bridges to sudo, or define an alias: $ alias doas=sudo.

The best long-term solution though would be to just use doas without any alias or shim, but our muscle memory may have trouble adapting to that, especially when sudo is still the de facto standard in most Linux distributions out there these days.